The 4% Rule: Complete Guide to Safe Retirement Withdrawals

Discover the essential, evidence-based approach that has guided millions to financial independence. Uncover its history, see how it works, explore modern criticisms and alternatives, and learn how to use this rule to create your own secure retirement plan.

What is the 4% Rule?

The 4% Rule is a retirement withdrawal strategy that suggests you can withdraw 4% of your initial retirement portfolio value each year (adjusted for inflation), and your money should last for at least 30 years. For example, if you retire with $1,000,000, you start by withdrawing $40,000 in the first year, then increase this amount by inflation each subsequent year.

Originated from the classic 1994 study by William Bengen
Designed to help retirees avoid outliving their savings
Assumes a balanced and diversified portfolio (typically, about 50-75% stocks and the remainder bonds)

The History: Origins & Research

Bill Bengen, an MIT graduate and financial planner, published a landmark 1994 paper analyzing U.S. stock and bond returns from 1926 onwards. He tested withdrawal rates across every 30-year period using historical data—including the Great Depression and high-inflation 1970s—to determine a “safe” rate for retirees.

Bengen found that a retiree using a 50/50 stock/bond portfolio could safely withdraw 4% of their nest egg—adjusted for inflation—without running out of money.

Read Bengen's influential research and 2024 reevaluation

Foundational research by Bill Bengen, MIT grad and the "father" of the 4% Rule.
Learn more on Wikipedia

How Does the 4% Rule Work?

The 4% Rule centers on a simple process: in your first year of retirement, withdraw 4% of your starting portfolio balance. Each subsequent year, you withdraw the same amount, adjusted upward for inflation. The idea is to keep your annual spending power steady while managing the risk of depleting your nest egg.

Step-by-step Example:

You retire with a portfolio of $1,000,000
In the 1st retirement year, withdraw 4%: $40,000
If inflation is 3%, in year 2 you withdraw $41,200
Repeat the process each year: always base new withdrawals on last year's withdrawal plus inflation

Interactive Retirement Simulator

Withdrawal Rate Year 1 Withdrawal %

0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10%

Portfolio Growth Rate Expected annual investment returns

2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12%

Withdrawal: 4.0%

Growth: 7.0%

Conservative

Traditional

Aggressive

Risky

With a 4.0% withdrawal rate and 7.0% average annual returns, you would initially withdraw $40,000 from a $1,000,000 portfolio. This creates a 3.0% positive gap between growth and withdrawals, which means your portfolio is likely to sustain withdrawals for the full 30-year retirement period.

Chart: Simulated portfolio growth and annual withdrawals with inflation adjustment over 30 years

Criticisms, Limitations & Modern Debate

Past Performance ≠ Future Results: The rule is based on historical US market returns, which may not repeat.
Sequence of Returns Risk: Withdrawing during a market downturn early in retirement may jeopardize your portfolio.
Changing Market Conditions: Low bond yields and increased volatility have prompted many experts to suggest even lower "safe" withdrawal rates (3.3%–3.7% as of 2025 per Morningstar).
Inflation: Periods of unusually high inflation stress the rule—your spending power may erode faster than expected.
Doesn't Personalize: Ignores factors like healthcare, taxes, outside income (e.g., Social Security), or large irregular expenses.
Longevity Risk: If you retire early or live an exceptionally long life, the classic 30-year span may not be enough.

Expert voices: Many financial planners now recommend blending the 4% rule with dynamic spending strategies and regular portfolio reviews.

Modern Alternatives & Enhancements (2024+)

Dynamic Withdrawal Strategies: Adjust withdrawals based on portfolio performance, market returns, or spending needs (see more).
Guardrails Approach: As popularized by Guyton/Klinger, this method raises or lowers withdrawals when the market or portfolio values hit certain thresholds.
Partial Annuities: Blending a portion of assets in annuities for guaranteed income, with the rest following withdrawal rules.
Bucket Strategies: Divide assets by time horizon (immediate cash, mid-term bonds, long-term stocks) to minimize the impact of market swings.
Personalized Safe Withdrawal Rate: Adjust the percentage based on age, risk tolerance, time horizon, and non-portfolio income sources.

2024 Expert Tip: Most experts now recommend using a 3.3%–3.8% starting withdrawal rate for new retirees, especially if retiring during volatile market conditions.

Practical Application: Should You Use the 4% Rule?

The 4% Rule is a valuable starting point for planning, but it's best used as a guideline, not a guarantee. Combine it with periodic reviews, personalized spending forecasts, and consider other assets and income sources (like Social Security, pensions, etc.).

Use a retirement calculator, such as fourpercentrule.com
Model your own portfolio, including real estate, pensions, and health care costs
Adjust your withdrawal rate based on market performance and personal circumstances
Consult with a fee-only fiduciary financial planner for truly comprehensive advice

Try the 4% Rule Retirement Calculator

Real-World Case Studies: The 4% Rule in Action

Case Study 1: Traditional Retirement (Age 65)

Anna retires at 65 with $800,000. She withdraws $32,000 the first year, increasing each year for inflation. Even through major market swings, her portfolio is projected to last at least 30 years 95% of the time (US market data).

Case Study 2: FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early)

Matt retires at 40 with $1.2 million. He uses the 4% rule, but adds a buffer: he spends 3.5% per year, knowing his horizon is closer to 50 years rather than 30. Periodic recalculations and side income from passion projects add safety.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the 4% Rule include Social Security or other guaranteed income?

No. The 4% rule generally applies only to portfolio investments (stocks/bonds). For a truly accurate income plan, factor in pensions, Social Security, and annuities separately—then reduce your withdrawal need accordingly.

Is the 4% Rule guaranteed to work for everyone?

No approach is guaranteed. The 4% rule is based on past US market data; individual circumstances, investment choices, and future market trends can vary widely. It serves as a guideline, not a one-size-fits-all rule.

Can I use the 4% Rule outside the United States?

The original research is based on US markets. Other countries with different investment climates may require lower rates. Seek local advice and consider using more conservative assumptions.

Where can I find credible calculators and research?

Check out the official 4% Rule Calculator, Morningstar research, and Kiplinger's expert guides for trustworthy information.

References & Further Reading

For press citations, please link directly to this page or reference the original peer-reviewed studies for academic use.

RETIREMENT PLANNER AND COMMUNITY - This site is under construction!